A lot of what Bill Maher says on Politically
Incorrect infuriates me. Maher's repeated Johnny-come-lately defense of the Vietnam War, and
more recently his ignorant pronouncements about
Middle Eastern history, are two of his worst offenses.
But I do agree with Maher, a fellow
vegan, on his pro-animal rights position. And the other night he
eloquently, with humor, said what others -- including me without his humor,
and perhaps without his eloquence -- have been trying to get across for so
long about global and domestic economic injustice, and the total failure of
American leadership in these realms.
So I wanted to share Maher's
words. Following are relevant excerpts from the transcript
of the program:
Now, [this] being our last show of
the year, I'd like to make a plea tonight for world peace. Oh, I know what
you're saying. "Bill, you've had enough controversy this year."
[ Light laughter ]
True that, but --
[ Laughter ]
This being Christmastime, I figure
it's my best shot to convince people of the unpopular position, that we
Americans need to start thinking of ourselves as citizens of the world
first and of any particular country second. After all, Jesus himself was,
I don't know if you know this, not an American.
[ Light laughter ]
If you celebrate Christmas
religiously, folks, you pray to a young man from the Middle East who,
today, probably would get stopped at the airport.
[ Laughter ]
...Folks, we are living in a global
village, and we need to become globalists.... we are living in a global
village, and now that the haters, the have-nots, can so easily get to and
inflict pain on the players, the haves, it is both a moral and selfish
imperative for us to realize that a village, even a global one, is only as
safe as its least safe and happy member.
So we can go on, as we have,
considering American lives more valuable than all others, hogging
resources and pulling out of treaties the rest of the world wants, or we
can get smart and realize that there's a human ecology just like there's
an ecology in nature. If you kill the spiders, you end up with too many
flies... The lack of food, an education, and alternatives to hate and
reasons to hope will produce terrorists.
God bless America? Sure. But Tiny
Tim said it better --"God bless us, every one."
[ Cheers and applause ]
...Thank you. And it's always easy
to applaud that, you know, in the abstract, but if I said to you,
"That means that we're going to have to have a massive redistribution
of our wealth that we might have to give up 10% to 15% of what we make so
that the rest of the world doesn't suffer and hate us," would you
agree with that?
[ Cheers and applause ]
Commenting later on political
leadership:
I never hear the president say
anything that makes people wanna do anything but what they have already
been doing all along. His big sacrifice is, "Shop, enjoy Christmas,
use more oil."
[ Laughter ]
That to me is not leadership.
Leadership is be willing to take it on the chin because you present people
with an option that may not be popular. That's what real leaders do.
[ Applause ]
And finally, the link to domestic
economic injustice:
[M]y last fruit basket of the year
goes to the author Barbara
Ehrenreich. She wrote a book called "Nickel
and Dimed," which was widely covered but not widely enough, where
she basically said, "Guilt does not go far enough. We should feel
shamed, all of us in the so-called "middle class," who depend on
the underpaid labor of others."
She took jobs as a waitress, a house
cleaner, and in Wal-Mart, and she said she wanted to find a simple
question. How can anyone in this country live on $6 or $7 an hour?
Now, the people we were just talking
about in the first segment who live in the third world might say,
"Gee, how can you live on that a week like we do?" But both
questions are good...
You know. We're a rich country, and
we're not sharing either here at home or overseas, and we are gonna pay
for it. That's my Christmas message.
I know Maher's comments were not a
scholarly presentation citing statistics for each of his assertions.
Maher was only trying to plant thoughts in people's minds. He did that
well. And when was the last time you heard anyone on the ABC
television network expressing thoughts like these, to millions of
viewers? It was heartening to behold. Kudos to Bill Maher for
doing so.